Beyond Johnny-Dome: Taking a Right Turn off of the Johnny Hunt Highway

“I wonder when we are ever going to change…We don’t need another hero.” Britten and Lyle

This is a post that was almost never written.  It’s one that has been in my mind for a long time, but I’ve not yet put word to processor to write it.  The time has never seemed right to do so.  If the time has ever been right, it’s right now.  Christians in the state of Georgia and beyond need a reminder that they shouldn’t put too much stock in any one man’s personality or accomplishments (unless, of course, than man is Jesus Christ).  One such man is Johnny Hunt, pastor of the First Baptist Woodstock megachurch and a hero of the conservative resurgence of the Southern Baptist Convention.  The false confidence that Georgia Baptists put in Hunt’s opinion of Ergun Caner last year has led to a lot of tragedy and heartache.   As many readers of this blog already know, Ergun Caner has recently resigned from the presidency of Brewton-Parker College among a brewing and secretive scandal.  CB Scott, a Vice President of that institution, was fired after he refused to sign a non-disclosure agreement.  In his words, he refused to sign the agreement and accept an attractive severance package “as a matter of personal integrity.”  Of course, CB Scott should have never been put in that position because the scandal-ridden charlatan Ergun Caner should have never been appointed as the President of Brewton-Parker or any other Christian institution…but he was…at the recommendation of Johnny Hunt, whose moral authority and charismatic allure (likely) helped legitimize Ergun Caner as a viable candidate.   Even though Johnny Hunt knew of Caner’s past charlatanry, he still backed him.  He even invited him to fill his pulpit last July.  I was a member of Hunt’s church at the time.  I am no longer.  Like CB Scott, I wouldn’t just sit silent in the face of scandal and shame.

Highway 92 Revisited

hunt highway

“I’ll be a big noise with all the big boys. There’s so much stuff I will own.  I will pray to a big God as I kneel in the big church.” Peter Gabriel

Georgia State Route 92 is 97.81 mile span of road that runs from Griffin to Roswell and through eight counties: Spalding, Fayette, Fulton, Douglas, Paulding, Cobb, and Cherokee.  In Cherokee County, a short portion of the highway between Neese and Trickum roads was renamed “Johnny Hunt Highway” in honor of the Pastor of the First Baptist of Woodstock (FBCW).  The renaming of this portion of Highway 92 was the brainchild of former Georgia State Senate Majority Leader, Chip Rogers (R-Woodstock), an active member of FBCW.  Rogers was named as one of “The Most Influential Georgians” by James Magazine in 2009.  On at least one occasion, while sitting in the congregation at FBCW, I heard Johnny Hunt give Chip Rogers a shout-out from the pulpit during a sermon.  FBCW is a voting precinct, I’ve witnessed Chip Rogers actively standing outside of his own megachurch holding a campaign sign to encourage people to go into the church building and vote for him.  Incidentally, a controversial real-estate deal in which Chip Rogers was involved “contributed significantly” to the failure of a Georgia community bank, according to the bank’s chairman.  Rogers was sued by the bank.  Incidentally, Rogers resigned his senate seat not long after it was revealed that he was involved in a sports-betting enterprise before his political career, advertising himself in videos as “Will the Winner” and encouraging callers to call a 900 hundred number for winning picks.  Gambling is frowned upon at FBCW.  Incidentally, I have to wonder how much discernment Hunt exercises when he chooses his influential, big time friends.

“…your arm felt nice wrapped ’round my shoulder…I had a feeling that I belonged. I had a feeling I could be someone. Tracy Chapman

While “Will the winner” is gone from the Georgia Senate, the Johnny Hunt Highway remains.  FBCW itself is located on this small stretch of highway.  However Hunt’s and FBCW’s influence is not limited to a plot of land on the side of Highway 92 in Woodstock, GA.  The church boasts three additional campuses, one of which in Panama City Beach, where Johnny’s daughter Deanna Hunt Carswell lives.

Deena Hunt

Hunt, a former president of the Southern Baptist Convention, presents conferences nationally.  He bestrides the narrow evangelical world like a colossus.  When Johnny Hunt speaks people listen…and his voice emanates each Sunday from the Johnny Hunt highway.

“I took a drive today, time to emancipate…Saw things so much clearer, once you were in my rearview-mirror”. Eddie Vedder

The last time I traveled the Johnny Hunt highway was Sunday July 27, 2014.  I had just been escorted off of the campus of FBCW by this rather large security officer in a black suit, wearing an earpiece, whom I’d never seen at church before:

ergun goon

I was escorted off the campus at the order of John Day, who directs security at FBCW and whose son was one of Johnny Hunt’s mentees.  Multiple witnesses have attested that I was not acting in a disorderly way.  My only offense was attempting to warn fellow church members about the charlatan Ergun Caner, whom Johnny Hunt had invited to fill the church’s pulpit that day.  (Johnny was on vacation at the beach that day, on a rented yacht I’m told, near the FBCW Woodstock campus in Panama City).

Posted to Johnny Hunt’s Instagram Account on 07/27/2014

My stance on Ergun Caner was starkly different than Hunt’s.  Before Ergun’s sermon…let me pause, I use that term loosely.  Caner just mentioned a bible passage and then talked about himself for 45 minutes.  I don’t think Allan Taylor, the education minister at Woodstock liked Caner’s 45-minute talk about himself much either as this July 29 tweet might indicate:

taylor tweet

Before Caner’s sermon began, a prerecorded video of Johnny Hunt was played for the crowd.  In the video Hunt, stated:

“Ergun, I love you my friend.  I’m grateful for the way God has used you and is using you.  Thank you for your humble spirit and the way you’ve just desired to serve…just know that Woodstock welcomes you this morning…thank you for honoring us by being here today…Woodstock, know that you are in a for a real treat.”

We were not, as Taylor’s tweet implies, in for a treat.  I’d never seen Johnny have to plug a guest preacher so much before.  Yet, he plugged Caner.  Perhaps he did so because he knew people had reservations about Caner. Caner is a known charlatan who is known to have used off-color racial language in the pulpit.  According to initial reports coming from Brewton-Parker, Caner used such language at the offense of many. At a chapel service at the school and a third of the student body walked out in protest of Caner.  This incident precipitated what many believe was a forced resignation.  However, Caner using such language was Caner being Caner…the same Caner that Johnny Hunt, Newsong, and Tony Nolan have known for years.  The reader may be perplexed at the point as to why I bring up Newsong and Tony Nolan.  Along with Hunt, these individuals have preached at conferences with Caner for years. Their connection is more than spiritual (and financial).  Hunt’s daughter is married to a member of the Carswell family, of Newsong fame.  Tony Nolan recently preached a revival at Brewton-Parker where it was claimed that 120 souls were saved at one time.  Johnny Hunt was on the board of Liberty University when Caner was the Dean of the theology school there.  Thick as thieves, they are.

Ergun Caner is one of Johnny Hunt’s big time buddies.

I am not.  I was just a pew-sitting, rank-and-file member of Johnny Hunt’s church.  I wasn’t one of his celebrity associates, he was just my pastor.  I couldn’t even get a meeting with him to talk about my concerns with Ergun Caner.  Maybe he would have met with Will the Winner.  When I tried to talk to the church about them, I was escorted off campus.  I was escorted off along with John Day’s own nephew, who had accompanied me to church that day.  His nephew is not a Christian.  We were on the way to Sunday School class when we were forced to leave.

I tried to warn my church about Johnny’s friend, Ergun Caner.  I was kicked off the campus for doing so.  I haven’t been back.  I drove off with John Day’s nephew and left the Johnny Hunt highway in my rear-view mirror for good.  I know of at least three other families that have left church in the wake of this scandal…out of hundreds who ignored or endured it.


The Political World of American Evangelicalism

We live in a political world. The one we can see and can feel; But there’s no one to check, it’s all a stacked deck. We all know for sure that it’s realBob Dylan

All this is water under the bridge.  I’m not bitter and I now have a pastor who’ll take a meeting with me.  He’s a great man, though, you’ve likely never heard of him.  He’s not an evangelical celebrity, he’s just a guy who will take a meeting with little pew-sitter like me.  I bring up these events of the past to show that we’ve let certain personalities in evangelicalism become too big to fail and those who speak out at their local church, like me, will just get escorted out the front door for dissenting.  CB Scott was fired from his job at Brewton-Parker for not pledging to keep his mouth shut about Caner.   Not fired in the wake of this latest Caner scandal, was Brewton-Parker VP, Peter Lumpkins, who recently likened Caner to Elijah.  The band plays on.  The political intrigue continues.

Over a year ago, I wrote about Caner’s ill-fated hire at Brewton-Parker.  So did James White, so did Mark Lamprecht, so did a lot of folks. The Trustees at Brewton-Parker listened to men like Johnny Hunt instead.  Ergun Caner and his friends were too big to fail…but they did.  Then they tried to sweep it under the rug…again.  People didn’t listen to my warning.  We need to use this latest incident as a catalyst to change the culture of evangelicalism.  Ergun Caner is not the problem, the environment is.  It’s a political world.  I said it a year ago, and I’ll say it again:

“To the best of my knowledge, Dr. Ergun Caner does not manage the financial stewardship of any Georgia Baptist church. Dr. Caner is just a man who was looking for a job in his field and found one. The Georgia Baptist leaders, specifically the trustees of Brewton-Parker, entrusted with the task of hiring the President of the institution are the ones responsible for installing Dr. Caner in that role. They dropped the ball. These men are the ones who should be held accountable by Georgia Baptists. These men and the institution they lead should be defunded immediately.”

Jesus said He would build his church.  Let’s stop looking to mega-pastors and personalities to do it for Him.  We don’t need another hero, we have Jesus.

“Thinking about formulas, what we’ve done. I’m 71 today, y’all know that? 71…and in the 50 years, I’ve been in the ministry…I’ve watched formulas, formulas of man’s opinion of how to do church. If you do this, this, this, this and this, you’re going to be big, big, and bigger…and I’m telling you, it’s like a virus! And it’s everywhere! And you know what, it sells. Publishers are grabbing these things and they’re heralding these mega-churches wherever they are and they’re heralding mega-preachers who’ve become gods and their selling their stuff and here’s the problem…people are buying it like you wouldn’t believe. They’re sucked right into a message that says, ‘You can build God’s church!’ when Jesus himself said, ‘I will build my church.’ Man’s creativity, God does not need. He’s needs man’s willingness to surrender to him.” Wayne Barber, preaching to the congregation at the church were I grew up on July 27th, 2014, the day of I was escorted out of FBCW.

To all the people who valued Johnny Hunt’s recommendation over the documented evidence of Caner’s incorrigible charlatanry…

I told you so.

*Please note that the preceding is my personal opinion. It is not necessarily the opinion of any entity by which I am employed, any church at which I am a member, any church which I attend, or the educational institution at which I am enrolled. Any copyrighted material displayed or referenced is done under the doctrine of fair use.

26 thoughts on “Beyond Johnny-Dome: Taking a Right Turn off of the Johnny Hunt Highway

  1. Michelle

    First let me say, I appreciate your faithfulness to Christ and your desire for truth and overall purity of the Church. My only suggestion with this particular piece is to leave the daughter’s pic out (for a couple of reasons). I know your message will be just as effective if not more so. – just a humble two cents from a sister in Christ.

    1. sethdunn88 Post author

      Thanks, Michelle. I appreciate the thought.

      That pic is Mrs. Carswell’s public twitter profile pic. It’s purpose in the piece is to show Hunt’s connection to PCB and Newsong.

      1. BetterThanPrinceCharming

        Hey, Seth. Me and my husband just moved to GA from South, FL. Looking for a home church and First Baptist of Woodstock is the first we visited, but missed the entire service and only got a tour of the children’s ministry. I am so blessed by your discernment. Was wondering if you’d mind letting me know where you attend service? Been praying and we want to be where God wants us to be.

      2. sethdunn88 Post author

        I am a member of Roland Springs Baptist in Cartersville. It’s about a half hour from where FBCW is.

        I have a friend who moved from Ohio just to sit under Johnny Hunt’s pastorship at FBCW. He left FBCW and now attends Household of Faith Bible Church at 530 Collins Road, Marietta, GA. I’ve never been there but he really likes it. It’s a family integrated church.

        My former Sunday School teacher at FBCW left and he struggled to find a good church in the area. I don’t envy your search.

        If you need anymore help please email me.

        Thanks for reading and good luck.

      3. BetterThanPrinceCharming

        Thank you for responding. No luck needed, we have Jesus 🙂 Question…

        So after reading this post, I went to the Lord and prayed and asked Him to speak to me. Before coming across this, I’d been thinking He wanted me and my family to attend Woodstock. But after reading this, I definitely did not like the evidence of greed. I happened to be in the early chapters of Revelation, and believed I needed to re-read the letters to the seven churches. Afterwards, I went into prayer with my sister. I began crying and the words that came out of my mouth were basically:

        I prayed for Johnny, that he would repent of any greed and sin and come back to really loving Jesus, even if that meant confessing to the congregation and stepping down for a time, as I believe David Wilkerson has allegedly done.

        Lord, if he does not, deal with him as you dealt with Jezebel, who taught your people to commit sexual immorality and to sacrifice to idols, whom you gave time to repent before exposing her and dealing with her.

        You did not tell your church to leave those churches, but told those who needed repenting to repent, and those who were faithful to continue being faithful.

        There were some who left Calvary Chapel Fort Lauderdale after Bob’s failure, but there were those who also stayed because they weren’t there for Bob, they were there because they loved that church, and the people there. Just as I met wonderful brothers and sisters at Calvary, I am sure there are those who are faithful to You at Woodstock.


        That was the gist of it. What are your thoughts on the fact that Jesus did not command the church to forsake one another, but rather, encouraged the areas where they were good, and then warned them to repent of the areas where they were wrong?

        Also, in speaking to “the angels” of the churches, He does warn about removing lamp stands, and again, He dealt with Jezebel, without commanding anyone to leave the fellowship. Which coincides with Paul’s teachings about removing people from you, but not forsaking the gathering of the brethren.

        In conclusion: I believe we are to remove people from fellowship if they are in certain unrepentant sins, and others, we trust Jesus to deal with, like He did with Jezebel, but in any case, we are not commanded to forsake.

        What do you say to this, brother? I sincerely would like to know, and thank you again for responding 🙂

      4. sethdunn88 Post author

        I think Matthew 18 and I Corinthians 5 give us a clear guidelines for enacting church discipline, removing someone in unrepentant sin from fellowship. However, fulfilling these guidelines requires a faithful and willing church. I think when one finds himself in a situation where his church, as a whole, is off the right path and shows no sign of getting back on track, the best thing is for him to find another congregation. A Christian should, of course, never not be a part of a local body. To not be a part of a local body would be an act of forsaking the church.

  2. Brian Watson

    Hi, Seth. Thanks for the add on Facebook. Just a quick comment: I first encountered Ergun Caner at a student event in Washington State in 2009. I had never heard of him before and this was about a year before I started hearing about him and his lies from James White. I can attest to what you said about his “sermons” (I believe he gave three over two days). They contained almost no Scripture. Instead, we received a heavy dose of “Butch” (what his wife calls him), his love for MMA, and all other sorts of braggadocio nonsense. I am quite sure he lied to us about his youth (the type of lies exposed by White and others). How this man could ever be hired to another ministry or Christian leadership position of any kind, without full repentance and admission of his lies, is beyond me. When this kind of stuff happens, I can only assume the charlatans involved don’t believe that God is real, that he knows their deceptiveness and venality, and that they will one day be found out.

  3. Concerned Christian

    You sure it’s not more about the fact the ladies are in bikinis, and you are trying to make them look cheap?

      1. Jon

        I think it’s tasteless. It doesn’t matter if they have it posted. Posting someone else’s wife’s pic on a blog about the things of God (so you claim) is not right. You would not want your wife’s pic out up. It doesn’t matter if they post it, you reposting it is kinda creepy.

      2. Jon

        Still is confusing. I’m sure on her acct there are many other pics you could’ve used. Unless you’re trying to paint a bad picture of Johnny and his family. I think better discernment from you would’ve been good. Again just my opinion. I would do reevaluate while you put it there if it was not for Godly reasons I would take it down.

    1. sethdunn88 Post author


      If you have a problem with Mrs. Carswell’s public and long-time Twitter profile picture, then I think you should take it up with Mr. and Mrs. Carswell. I’ve clearly stated the reason for the picture’s inclusion in this blog.

      1. sethdunn88 Post author

        What about that particular picture, Jon, makes Mrs. Carswell or her father look bad?

        The image shows her locations as Woodstock and PCB, two places where FBCW has campuses. That’s the context of the picture’s inclusion. Mrs. Carswell listed those locations herself and picked her own profile pic.

        From our interactions on Twitter, if this is the same Jon, I gather that you’d like this whole piece taken down not just that one picture.

      2. Jack Jennings

        You’re a butthurt whistle blower all because someone didn’t pay enough attention to you. You’ve been like this your whole life. Pretty pathetic! You also have a crush on his daughter. She must have turned you down. Sucks doesn’t it

  4. Jon

    His daughter doesn’t live in Panama City. I also think you should remove that pic. Also it seems you are bitter for being asked to leave. Just my 2 cents…

  5. Bill N

    I love the Wayne Barber quote. I’ve known him for many years via Mississippi and Precept, Intl connections. While Wayne is high-spirited,he also preaches and teaches what the Bible says and submits himself to it.

    1. sethdunn88 Post author

      I’ve been listening to Brother Wayne preach since I was 6.

      You should have seen me when I heard Brother Wayne preach that. I was in the car on Tuesday morning, two days after I was kicked off the campus of that megachurch. Brother Wayne was preaching that, at the church were I grew up on 7/27/14, at almost the same time that I was getting escorted off of the grounds of FBCW.

      I was in Calhoun, but I bet people could hear me praising the Lord in my car clear to Chattanooga. No joke, the name of the road I was driving on is Damascus Road.

      The Lord is faithful.

  6. opieandy

    This is a fantastic piece. I come from a different perspective than you all. I read the Bible through many times, studied it, taught Sunday School,, and went to seminary. I eventually (over the course of almost 20 years) concluded the Bible is not the infallible and inerrant word of God because it is plain to see. (Ps. 137:9 is my favorite verse, though). But it took many years to undo my thinking on that subject. Those years partially occurred while I was at FBCW (spanning approximately 2003-2010). Though I was drifting away from Christianity, I always respected Johnny Hunt greatly and enjoyed his ministry. Who knows what is really in the heart of man, but he seemed a sincere, credible, impactful leader. I look forward to reading more on Johnny and perhaps the real reason he recently decided to leave FBCW. I do know many of the sincere Christians I knew from FBCW have left since I departed. And I’m sure many good, sincere Christians. It has many of the same flaws most evangelical churches have, but it did have many sincere people, which was refreshing. It’s always funny and disconcerting to see the Christian-speak that folks use, such as in these replies.



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s